Green products and services are receiving much positive press, and getting lots of attention. Global warming is the impetus. But are all green products and services effective and worthy of attention? For example, what can we conclude based on the following:
- Hybrids get greater gas mileage but during recharging cycles, they spew carbon into the skies, as power needed to recharge the batteries probably comes from a plant burning coal or petroleum sources, which make up a large majority of the energy sources feeding U.S. power plants.
- Energy-efficient fluorescent bulbs burn longer and require less energy but contain mercury and if disposed improperly the mercury poisons our soil and ground water.
- Nuclear is non-polluting, until we measure the waste issues.
- Cotton is natural but requires as much energy to turn into a shirt or a blouse as does polyester.
What to do?
Whether you are a business operator or an individual, I recommend you measure the size of your environmental footprint. Start with your present state and work toward a future state that reduces your footprint.
How big is it?
To measure your footprint, you must first commit yourself to doing so. I read lots and lots of folks talking about green or criticizing others for not being greener--especially the business haters--but my first question is to all those who write, lobby or talk for green: "What size is your footprint?" Because talk is cheap and having been an activist for a variety of causes, both on the right and the left (I am unaligned with any political party), I observed more than a few who are good at being loud and at calling for change but who are not so good at changing their own behaviors. They hurt the cause. Having been a talker instead of a walker, I must now walk the talk with all those also finding the path to doing good. Therefore, I must first ask that question. I did. The answer wasn't so great. I can do better. And I must do better.
After Lead With Your Heart was published, wherein I call on businesses to do good, not out of altruism but because it is good for the planet and for business, I committed myself to being a better caretaker of the planet and to reach out more often to help those who need a hand-up (not a handout). Now I must walk the talk. And that is where the second step comes in.
Once we commit, we must educate--both ourselves and others. I began with something I already knew a bit about. Compact Fluorescent bulbs, also called Energy Saving Bulbs. They have come a long way since I first purchased one in 1993, when I worked as a manager with a utility company. Then, they cost too much and they didn't fit lamps with shades. Both issues have been resolved, and the issue of their mercury being safely recycled is being worked on. Bearing an average life of 10,000 hours, I am confident the mercury problem will be solved before I need to replace the dozens of bulbs I purchased and installed in our offices and my home a few months back.
On the other hand, Hybrids do little to reduce my environmental impact. Their mileage standards are not much better than either of our current cars and might in fact not reduce our current carbon emissions. Instead, we drive less and take the train more. Not a perfect solution but we are confident that doing so reduces our footprint. Furthermore, we try to conduct most client communication and conversation using e-mail, fax and telephones, to avoid driving.
As for paper, we use very little. We do not print anything unless it is absolutely necessary, and we recycle every piece of paper we produce or receive in the mail or otherwise. We also recycle all glass and plastic that is recyclable. When I say we, I mean both in the business and in my home.
The above areas are the ones we have focused on in our business and our personal lives. It is a start but our footprint remains too large. And we will do more. But none of what we do decreases either our bottom line or our quality of life. And that is the primary point of this post, where we use our small efforts as examples to make a bigger point, which I also make in Lead With Your Heart.
If we expect altruism to drive doing good, we execute on a bad strategy. And if we criticize business for doing good only because it benefits their image and/or their bottom line, we miss the point. Those of us who believe doing good is smart and the right thing to do need to get on the same page. And that page depicts doing good, no matter the motivation behind it. Results matter. Motivation and inspiration for results can come from many places and it can take many forms. Who cares where it bubbles up, certainly not the planet or those being helped.
The planet and those being helped only know that good is happening. They don't judge the means creating that good, for doing so is foolish and unproductive. Good is good. That's it! If you want good to happen, do something positive. Walk the talk and remove your critic's hat and only put it back on when you find harm being done. Finally, let's first put our own houses in order before we take a critical look outside our windows.