Informing or Evangelizing: Turn Down the Volume.
We often talk about brand, products, and services evangelizers and tout evangelizing
as a great way to build brand. But can it backfire on us? Can evangelizing equate to false prophets in the minds of those touched by evangelizers?
I ask these questions because many of us consultants work daily to put in place processes that result in evangelizing our client's brand, products, services and value propositions. We might need to take a step back and ask ourselves if we sometimes do more harm than good.
Recently, I was asked to conduct a workshop called "Old Media vs. New Media." The immediate feedback from attendees was that we achieved success. However, the workshop surveys showed a somewhat different general response. One person struck a high chord. He equated what was being said as social media evangelizing, not as a forum for information, which was the workshop's purpose. And for him, and several others, evangelizing leads to skepticism. Having never thought about that previously, I now have cause to wonder if evangelizing leads us where we want to go.
Now, let it be said, I was passionate in the workshop. Any speaker should be, no matter the subject matter. However, I also made it very clear that social media needed to be approached with caution by businesses and that social media does not represent anything more than new tools that allow some different approaches to engaging customers. To at least a few, that message was lost. Not surprising. Our experiences result in our perceptions of what we hear, read and watch.
Knowing that, we must be careful in evangelizing and in creating brand evangelists. In fact, I believe evangelizing is not what we should be seeking. All of us know that the word itself carries baggage, as many people see evangelists as blinded to reality by their beliefs. The last thing we should want for our clients are company and consumer spokespersons who create that perception, which results in three groups of people carrying three perceptions of our clients:
- Those who believe our clients are great.
- Those who are unmoved by our clients and the evangelists.
- And those who are pushed to lash back at our clients because of the evangelism.
To some extent, groups 1 and 3 cancel each other out. Not a good business result.
To avoid that, we marketers and brand consultants should first rid our vocabulary of the words evangelizing and evangelists, and replace them with an older phrase: word of mouth marketing. Then, instead of producing strategies and tactics to create brand evangelists, the strategies and tactics should be lowered in volume with the goal to create realistic and believable company and consumer spokespersons who see the good and the bad in what we and our clients do.
The results: Instead of evangelists, we will have loyal customers, who when asked or offered an opportunity to comment on a brand, product or service will appear as a trustworthy and credible admirer of the business we represent or of our business. In other words, let's inform, not evangelize. Let's turn down the volume just a notch.

You are your brand. No ifs, ands or buts. Unless you work for another, then you are their brand. Why? Because brand isn't a logo, or letterhead, or an ad or a viral video. Brand is human. And Brand image is what others think of that human. In your case, your brand is what others think of you. It's their perception of you. So if you are one of those who claim they don't care what others think, be prepared to live with a brand that sucks and doesn't get noticed. But if you recognize the value of you, then read on and learn how to be a brand star.
accoutrements. It will be great fun, Kay will be appreciative and we will learn things about each other that we didn't know. That's what happens at celebrations.
How do I know this, as the opening pitch is yet to be thrown? Am I psychic? An eternal optimist? A dreamer? Or maybe just a good marketer? To find out, visit Becky Carroll's Customers Rock!, where today I guest post. 

look at Wal-Mart.
The first installment asks that question about Starbucks.